Bella MacLeod's Twilight Fanfiction

Winner Takes All

By BetterInTexas

Chapter 12:

BPOV

Holy Hell. The minute I locked eyes on Peter and Garrett I knew. I could never choose between them. I thought that when I was human. Now I knew. The problem was it didn’t work when I was human. I mean it worked damn well all night but I still remember what happened when I walked back into their apartment.

Since I kissed them both I haven’t had any other real interaction. I smoked a cigarette which did absolutely nothing for me but the familiarity of it was soothing. It gave me something to focus on. Let me drown out the lust I was feeling and the sights and the noises coming from miles away.

Then I realized I was hungry. My throat was killing me. I needed… blood.

Peter and Garrett offered to take me hunting. I refused. I didn’t live and die to protect humans so I could feed off them now. I didn’t give a damn how guilty they were of whatever crime it was they committed. Peter and Garrett could do what they wanted. I was planning on feeding from animals. I had thought about this before. You can’t hang around and talk to vampires and not think about it. I had always wondered what I would do but I knew in my heart. I didn’t have it in me to kill to feed. I had killed a man once. It was self-defense. I had shot another man to save his victim. But purposely going after people, even criminals, I just didn’t have in me.

That led me to this forest with Rose and Esme. Alice was apparently finding a new wardrobe for me. I shuddered to think about it.

My breasts had gotten slightly larger. My lines were sharper and I actually had muscle tone. I don’t think I had gotten taller. But Alice pointed out that I couldn’t go back to my apartment and pick up my old clothes. I was dead now. At least missing and presumed dead. I would have to check out the news once I found a meal. I thought the idea of killing an animal and drinking its blood would repulse me. But I could smell those fuckers around me.

They smelt good.

I could hear it moving. I hopped into a tree without even thinking about it. That was so fucking cool.

50 yards away I saw him. Black Bear. Big son of a bitch too.

“Give in to your instincts Bella.” Rose whispered.

I did. My instinct told me it was dinner time. He never saw me coming. I landed on top of him and twisted his thick neck. The smell was driving me crazy and my teeth went straight to his neck. The fur parted and suddenly I was being filled with the most glorious substance. I swear this was better than alcohol. I drank until there was nothing to drink. I felt Esme pulling me off.

“I think you did him in dear.” I turned around and she was smiling. Rose looked like she was about to laugh.

“What?” I asked.

“Nothing Bella. Don’t worry about a thing. Rose brought you clothes to change into.” Esme said glancing down my body. I looked at my shirt and jeans.

“I seemed to have made a mess haven’t I?” I was covered in blood. I looked like a freaking zombie.

Rose patted me on the back. “No problem girl. You will get better.”

“Thanks guys. For coming with me.”

“You know Bella, if I knew you were so dead set about becoming a vampire I would have just done it. You really didn’t have to attack a werewolf.” Rose said.

“If you guys had been able to handle him I wouldn’t have had to pick up the slack, bitch.” I smiled back.

“Yeah right, Dirty Harry. You want some more or are you good?”

Was I? My throat didn’t hurt as badly.

“Why don’t we head back? I don’t want to gorge myself. There won’t be any humans around will there?”

“No Bella.” Esme answered.

“Then let me change clothes. Can one of you help me? I don’t want to rip any clothes and have to run back naked.”

“Yeah because that would really bother the majority of males in that house.” Rose pointed out.

Oh yeah.

“Rose, about that…”

“Yeah. I heard what happened after your slumber party with the boys. Give them a chance Bella. I think seeing you nearly die may have focused them on what’s important.”

“Rose… I don’t know. They have been friends for years, but both of them? How is this even possible?”

“Maybe you are just too much vampire for one guy to handle?” Esme offered. Rose and I both looked at her in surprise.

“What? Be happy, Bella. I love Carlisle but the idea of getting one of your men in bed with us. The thought makes me… never mind. Forget I said anything.”

I looked at Rose and we both started laughing.

“Esme! You damn freak!”

“Oh please Rose. Like the idea hasn’t crossed your mind since all this two mates talk came up with Bella.”

“It certainly has not! Okay, maybe a little.” Rose grinned.

“You are both freaks. It’s not all it’s cracked up to be.” I mumbled.

“Oh that’s right. I forgot with the whole killing evil werewolves’ thing. Tell us what it was like Bella. You got a taste as a human. How was it?” Rose asked with an evil smile.

Damn it. I should have kept my mouth shut.

“It was… okay.”

“Okay?” Esme asked. She knew I was lying.

“Okay it was fucking fabulous. I can’t imagine a better sexual experience. Happy now?”

“No. We want details.” Rose countered.

“I am not giving you details of my sex life!”

“Why not? You did before you wound up as the meat in a hot guy sandwich. Why is this different?”

I was about to respond when Esme popped in again.

“Did you let them do you in both places at the same time?”

“You mean my mouth and…”

“No. I mean your front and back entrance dear.”

“ESME!” Rose and I both yelled. Then Rose looked at me.

“So did you?” She asked.

“No! I was human, you know. I could only take so much.”

“Apparently you could take quite a bit.” Rose said wiggling her eyebrows.

“So the thought never crossed you mind Bella?” Esme wouldn’t let it go.

“Yes. I mean it did but there was no way I was going to do that as a human.”

“But now?” Rose wouldn’t let it go either.

“I would… consider it. But honestly I don’t even think this will work. I mean…”

“You have to take control, Bella.” Esme said placing a hand on my shoulder and looking me in the eye.

“What do you mean?”

“They are boys at heart. All men are. They don’t want to share their toys. You have to show them that they are the toy. You have to let them know what you expect and that it is non-negotiable.”

“How am I supposed to do that Esme?”

“You shoved a silver dagger in a werewolf’s eye socket. You will figure it out. But in your relationship with those two you have to be the leader. You can’t let them fight over you, trying to pull you in different directions. It’s going to be a long existence if that is the case. If you are concerned with them only having you, bring a girl in bed with you. I’m sure Tanya or Irina wouldn’t mind.”

“You want me to share them?!”

“No. But Edward and Rose both told me you may have played for the opposite team in College a few times. In the spirit of honesty Bella this isn’t a stretch for you. I’m just saying that once the newness of this wears off and you aren’t a newborn, make a friend and have a little fun. I mean you have an opportunity here for a lot of great sex with a body with heightened senses that is extremely sensitive to touch and never gets tired, only limited by your imagination. So don’t limit your imagination. That’s all I’m saying dear.”

Rose was looking at Esme like she was from another planet. I had no idea she was this much of a freak. Then I remembered the look on her face when she burst from the floor during the battle with Andrie covered in werewolf blood. There may be a lot I don’t know about Esme.

“So you are saying you would share them with another woman, Esme?”

“Not for a few decades. I would make them service every single need I had. But in thirty or so years, sure. You have to think long term, Bella. You’re a vampire now dear.”

“Okay then. Why don’t we head back?” Rose suggested, still carrying a shocked expression on her face.

“First let me get changed.” I wondered if it was a good idea to change in front of Esme now. Oh well.

Garrett POV

“So how do you want this to work?” Peter asked.

“I don’t have a clue. I think we should follow her lead. Whatever she wants, we give it to her.” I said.

“Yeah. We have to get over this jealousy. Now that you know we are both… mated for lack of a better word… do you still think I was lying about feeling pulled to her?”

“No. Edward Cullen wouldn’t lie about that. If he was going to lie about anything it would be that she was meant for him. I’ll give him credit. The little shit hasn’t taken advantage of this situation.”

“Yeah. Almost makes me want to call up some old friends and see if I can’t get him laid.” Peter responded, laughing lightly.

“Yeah. So about who gets her when…” I was kind of curious as to his thoughts.

“Yeah, like you said, we should probably do what she tells us too.”

I nodded. Peter was the one talking sense. Strange. I should probably shut up and listen.

“Just so we are clear. Whatever we do, your ass better be real careful not to touch mine.” He grumbled.

“I honestly can’t believe you felt the need to say something so obvious to me.”

“I’m just saying. I mean Bella… just in case she ever gets some weird ideas… we have to stand firm on this. That’s all I’m saying.”

“Agreed. There are some limits she will have to respect.” Damn straight there were limits.

“You think she may ever get it on with another girl?” Peter asked looking at me and grinning.

“Doubtful. I know I have no interest in other women. But I wouldn’t mind watching her. I mean that would be great. But she doesn’t strike me as the type who would do that.”

“Are you kidding Garrett?”

“What?”

“She had casual sex with her partner and let him eat pizza off her pussy. She had sex with two vampires at the same time as a human. We have no clue what she is capable of.”

He had a point.

“She should be back soon. Why don’t we head to the house?” I offered.

“Yeah. I never imagined she would want to eat animals. You think she is going to give us shit about humans?”

“Yes Peter, I do. I don’t think she would say anything but she would probably not be happy about it and make her displeasure known in less obvious ways.”

“Great.” He mumbled. “What ways?”

May as well fuck with him. “I would bet if one of us were to start feeding from animals that one would get more attention. I’m considering feeding from animals anyway. I want her happy.” I really wasn’t. But if she asked me, how could I tell her no?

“Yeah me too.”

“You should probably start now, Peter.” I told him with my best serious face.

“Why don’t you?”

“I’m not hungry.”

“Me neither.”

“Your eyes are black.” I smiled. He took a deep breath and cringed.

“Fine. I’ll do it. One bear coming up.” He took off before I could tell him I was fucking with him. Oh well. Maybe he will like it. I ran back to the house and arrived just as Bella, Rose and Esme came into the yard. Damn I wanted to throw her down and fuck her. I walked directly up to her.

“Garrett.” She smiled.

“Bella.” She was so beautiful.

“Where is Peter? I think we all need to talk.”

“He is actually hunting.”

“He went to the city?” Bella was frowning.

“No. He actually went after a bear I believe.” I laughed lightly.

“That is so damn sweet! He is doing that for me, isn’t he? Oh my God, that is so great. God, I can’t wait to see him.” She looked like she just got a Christmas gift.

“I can go get him for you. I actually wanted to feed myself. He said he would be looking for a couple of potential targets. I just wanted to wait until you came back so you would know where we were.”

“Garrett that is so sweet of the two of you.” She whispered.

“Anything for you Bella.” Guess I was going to suck down some nasty blood. Damn it!

BPOV

“So how did that go?” I asked my girls as soon as Garrett was out of site.

“Excellent Bella. Within seconds you solved the potential problem of dietary differences and you really had to put no effort into it. The force is strong in you.” Esme responded.

“You like Star Wars, Esme?” I asked surprised.

“What is Star Wars?” she responded and walked inside. I looked at Rose who shrugged her shoulders.

Alice had made it back with my wardrobe. She also had several old jeans she bought from a resale store that I was to use for practice.

I moved to sit and Emmett tackled me and threw me over his shoulder. Then I was spinning.

“You are so much more fun now that I can throw you around without being careful!”

“Emmett put the newborn down!” Rose yelled.

He sat me on the couch while I regained my equilibrium.

“How are you doing Bella?” Carlisle asked. Edward was right behind him, being quiet and watching the television. He looked like he was in heavy thought.

“Uh, it’s very strange. The strength, the speed, the vision, everything. It’s just so much.”

“How was feeding?”

“Damn good Carlisle. I mean that shit tasted awesome. If I had known it was that good I would have been drinking blood a long time ago.”

“Glad to see you are adjusting so well Bella. The key will be when the time comes to take you around humans.” Jasper said, walking in with Alice wrapped around him.

“Oh hey Bella, I got you a newborn gift.” Emmett said suddenly.

“A newborn gift?”

“Yeah it’s a video of two guys and girl threesomes. Lots of different positions. It’s in my room. You can grab it whenever you want. Wouldn’t want one of your boys left out. It’s important to make them both feel like they are a part of the experience. Sorry Edward. I looked for three guys and a girl but there is only so much room in there if you know what I mean. Add another male and things could get ugly. Dicks could wind up in places dicks were not meant to go.” Emmett laughed.

No one else did.

“Emmett baby, I love you but sometimes you just need to shut the hell up. Seriously.” Rose said sadly.

“I’m sorry baby. I talked again, didn’t I?”

“It’s okay Emmett. We know you can’t help it.” I patted his hand. “Just sit there and flex your muscles okay?”

“Okay Bella. But I really do have the video if you want to check it out.”

Rose slapped him in the head. I really did kind of want to watch it. I looked at her had she winked at me. Guess I would be doing research later.

I asked for the news to be turned on. Edward flipped it to CNN. Damn. CNN?

I guess he read my expression.

“You have not been declared dead but between the rescue of the two girls and the burning of the building with you blood soaked car in front it is becoming pretty apparent that something bad went down involving the serial killer you were after. They are still sifting through the remains of the fire. Bones have been found of both canine and human nature but were apparently too burned for DNA identification. Jasper talked to a friend of his who is involved on the outskirts of the criminal justice field. No one knows what happened but the working theory is you were ambushed, and taken in your car to the building where the girls were most likely held. Despite the amount of blood found in the car, since the girls escaped it is believed you and the killer had some sort of showdown resulting in both your deaths and the burning of the building you were in. The whereabouts of your body remain a mystery.”

“The girls?”

“Remember being kidnapped by a gang of men, caged, surrounded by men and then later dogs and then waking up in front of the police station. They have no idea how they got there.” Carlisle said.

“Sounds like a good wrap up I guess. When do you think they will declare me dead?” I asked, thinking of Charlie and Renee.

“It will be a couple years, Bella. You are presumed dead but they won’t close the case until they know you are gone for certain.” Jasper answered. “You will have to stay very low until then. You may be a vampire but you haven’t changed that much. If someone saw you they would know it was you.”

I nodded my head. I knew this. I just had to stay low.

I heard Peter and Garrett run back into the front yard. I needed to get this talk over with. I stood up and began walking outside. Edward called my name.

“Yeah?”

“Don’t let them hurt you Bella.” He said without looking at me.

I nodded and took a deep breath.

I walked out and saw them fighting. No. They were laughing. Playing around. I had to smile. I was glad they weren’t at each other’s throats.

“You boys having fun?”

Damn it. They both turned on me with that look. The same look I was giving them. Despite knowing we needed to talk I had one thing on my mind. Two things actually and they were both right in front of me.

“I don’t suppose you men found a secluded spot we could all talk, did you?”

“Yeah. We may know of a spot.” Peter grinned.

“Lead the way men. It’s important that we… talk. I really, really want to talk right now.”

Garrett smiled and took my hand. “Then by all means Bella. Let’s go talk.”

I followed them two miles into the woods. We arrived at a hidden pond surrounded by trees.

Peter and Garrett were standing in front of me. There was quite a bit of tension in the air.

“So what do you want to talk about darlin?” Peter whispered.

“You both said you loved me before you turned me. I don’t… I think… I know I am falling for the two of you. That’s the problem. No amount of time will help me make a decision. I realize with this mating thing we have to be around each other. But I was wrong to tell you that you couldn’t be with another. If you want we can make this work. Find a way to be around each other and let you have normal relationships. You shouldn’t have to share me.”

I had to give them an out.

“No.” Garrett responded.

I looked at Peter.

“You are my mine the same as you are his. We both love you. You are more than enough.” He said, in a serious tone. He didn’t even say ain’t or ya’ll.

“No fighting?”

“No fighting Bella.” Garrett whispered, stepping closer.

“No jealousy?”

“No jealousy Bella.” Peter whispered, stepping around to my back. They were circling me.

“You belong to me? Both of you?”

“Yes.” Garrett whispered. His lips dipped down and brushed the hollow of my neck.

“Okay. I think that is all I wanted to talk about.” I whispered.

“We have some issues to talk to you about Bella.” Peter murmured in my ear from behind.

“Yeah?”

“If one of us wants to be with you when the other isn’t around, that’s okay.” Garrett whispered.

“It is?”

“Yes. As long as you are up for it.”

“Okay. Anything else?”

“Just one thing darlin. Never, under no circumstances, are we ever going to touch each other whether you think it might be hot or not.”

“Okay. Strange. I wasn’t planning on asking that, but good to know.”

“One more thing Bella. This is very important. It will take some fighting of our natural instincts to share you. You have to understand, and you yourself well understand, that vampires are territorial. We mark what is our own and don’t like others touching it without our permission. So if you are going to have Peter and me….”

“You better be damn careful not to flirt with anyone else or that someone else could wind up in a campfire. We will belong to you. But you are damn sure going to belong to us. Got it?” Peter finished. Damn they smelt good.

“Yeah.” I whispered. I closed my eyes and Peter ran his hands up my shirt and under my bra. My skin felt it was on fire. I sucked in a deep breath. Garrett unbuttoned my blue jeans and slipped his hand in. I was died with a Brazilian and it carried over. I hope he liked it. By the feel of his fingers he did. Oh shit he just slipped a finger inside me. I whimpered. Esme told me I had to take the lead.

I was going to take the lead.

“So who wants me first?”

Peter answered whispering in my hair.

“I was the first inside you when you were human. It’s Garrett’s turn.”

I raised my arms and Peter pulled my shirt off and unhooked my bra. Garrett pulled my jeans down to my ankles and I kicked out of my shoes and stepped out of my panties and jeans. Garrett’s tongue was one my pussy. Oh damn. I noticed briefly Peter laying his shirt on the ground and Garrett lay me on top of it. I spread my legs and looked down. I saw his beautiful hair coating my abs. My head was in Peter’s lap. They seemed more relaxed this time. It made me more relaxed. Peter laid my head on the ground. He stood to the side.

I stopped him.

“You are going to watch me right? Us?”

“You want me too?”

“Yes.”

“Then that is what I will do.”

“Stay where I can see you. I want to see you watch my body move. I want to know you are excited and ready to be in my next.”

“Yes ma’am.” I watched him take his clothes off and sit at the base of a tree. He was excited. Damn was he was excited. I looked up and Garrett was there. I kissed him. I could feel him at my entrance.

“Garrett? You don’t have to hold back.”

He smiled and brushed my hair off my face.

“I wasn’t planning to Bella.”

His hands gripped my waist and I felt him enter me completely in one stroke. I screamed. It wasn’t a scream of pain. I’m a screamer.

I lay there with my eyes open, staring into his while he fucked me. The constant pressure, the feel of electricity across our skin. I looked to the side and saw Peter looking at me with intense eyes.

“Flip me over Garrett.” I whispered while crooking a finger at Peter. He was on his knees in front of me before I landed on all fours. I took his cock in my mouth all the way to his balls, surprised and then remembering I didn’t have a gag reflex anymore.

This went on for hours. Garrett and Peter would switch places constantly. I made sure they were both satisfied. Multiple times. They did the same. I wanted to spend one on one time with both of them, but for now, this was perfect. This couldn’t get any better.

“Hey Bella have you ever thought about having… uh…” Peter started.

“Anal sex Bella. He is asking about anal sex.”

Oh fuck. I suppose it’s like Esme said. Don’t limit your imagination Bella.

I took a deep breath.

“I’ve never done it before.”

“We understand…” Peter started before I interrupted.

“So who is on the bottom and who is on the top?”

They both smiled and I was on top of Garrett who was still deep inside me. I felt Peter behind me. This was going to be a unique experience.